Dying Patient´s Organs - 1328 Words

The choice of what to do with a dying patients organs has always been a debate in the medical field. The debate of this situation is between a doctor, Tom, and a very ill patient, Mary. Mary is said to die soon and has deteriorating organs that if taken now are still viable to donate, but will surely kill Mary. The issue is that Mary still believes she will survive even when the truth is that she will die. Tom has three patients in need of organs waiting for Mary’s organs and will survive with the donation. The final decision is that Tom takes Mary’s organs and gives them to the patients. With the article â€Å"Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals† by Immanuel Kant, his theory of the Categorical Imperative and his process of the Formula of Universal Law, I will defend that Tom the doctor made the wrong decision in taking Mary’s organs and giving them away. I will also show John Stuart Mill’s theory of the Greatest Happiness Principle and how it measures the happiness of humans with the use of the three ingredients: consequentialism, hedonism, and impartiality and how this theory falls short to Kant’s. To begin, Mill would take the situation of Tom and Mary and say that Tom made the right choice in giving away Mary’s organs. Mill has a theory that all moral decisions should be chosen only to promote the greatest amount of happiness overall because that is the goal that all beings strive for. This is called the Greatest Happiness Principle (GHP). Mill explains in his articleShow MoreRelatedEuthanasia Essay : Euthanasia Of Humans1228 Words   |  5 Pagesclear. Since June 2016, euthanasia of humans is legal in the Netherlands, Belgium, Colombia, and Luxembourg and Medical Assistance in Dying is legal in Switzerland, Germany, Japan, Canada, and in the US states of Washington, Oregon, Colorado, Vermont, Montana, Washington DC, and California. In Canada a bill was passed on June 17, 2016, to activate regulated assisted dying. This means suicide of a person afflicted by an incurable disease, using a lethal dose of drugs provided by a doctor. To be eligibleRead MoreLife Support For Dying Patients1469 Words   |  6 Pagesfor dying patients has been an ongoing topic and has caused a lot of controversy. One side feel that dying patients should be kept on life support because life support increases the chances of survival, it allows families to come to terms with death, also it allows organ donation. The other side of this case point of view feels like life support is only prolonging life, supporting life support drains resources, and the ethical issue behind life support. I strongly believe that dying patient shouldRead MoreEuthanasi A More Humane Option For Suffering And Dying Patients1328 Words   |  6 Pageshumane option for suffering and dying patients. Afterall, death row inmates have the option of lethal injection because it is more humane, so why are competent patients not given the same option? Why do we allow people who committed serious crimes to have a humane death, but force innocent patients with severe illnesses, to suffer through the pain? Giving a suffering patient the option to end their misery in a relatively quick and painless way would not only ease their dying process, but it would alsoRead MoreBenefits Of Organ Donation For Organs1670 Words   |  7 Pageseach year due to organ complications; however, donating organs has become widely popular in the medical field to help save hospitalized people. Organ donation is a process in which a healthy individual gives up a working organ to an ailing person i n need. A person in decent health can be qualified to donate a kidney, liver, or various other organs. In some cases organ donors are deceased but the donors already planned to donate their organs. Both the person searching for an organ and the donor haveRead MoreEuthanasi The Act Of Killing Someone Painlessly1251 Words   |  6 Pagesfrom obligation, change, or penalty.† Physician assisted death is considered death and not suicide due to the fact that a physician is administering the medication instead of a patient doing the act themselves. Some people argue that legalized euthanasia is murder, but it is a well known fact that euthanasia ends a patient s agonizing pain, and puts less stress on their families when it comes to health care payments. Euthanasia, or physician assisted death has many pros and cons. Everyone has theRead MoreEthical Dilemm Moral Dilemma1415 Words   |  6 PagesEthical dilemma(s) One ethical dilemma Anthony has encountered is helping the family understand where their loved one is currently standing. Communicating life threatening news takes courage and certain factors need to be taken into consideration. In the textbook, The Last Dance it is stressed that physicians must â€Å"consider the patient’s personality, emotional constitution, and capacity for continued function under stress.† Communication is essential and how and when the life threatening news isRead MoreThe Ethical And Moral Issues Of Organ Transplantation1014 Words   |  5 PagesOrgan transplantation has been one of the most riveting medical advances of the century as it literally gives the chance of a lifetime to patients with terminal failure of vital organs. This requires the participation of other people in society to donate organs from their deceased family or even donations from living individuals themselves. The increasing incidence of vital organ failure and the inadequat e supply of organs has created a wide gap between organ supply and demand. This has resultedRead MoreAssisted Suicide Should Be Option1691 Words   |  7 Pagesthe potential for vital organs to be saved is much greater. As the sickness starts to take over many patients become too ill to do daily activities on their own but, with assisted suicide, the patient can die with dignity knowing that they saved themselves and their family time, money, and also heartbreak. As assisted suicide is discussed among many groups one must also take a look at the alternatives offered. As definition states, assisted suicide is the suicide of a patient suffering from an incurableRead MoreShould Euthanasia Be Practiced?1622 Words   |  7 Pageseuthanasia is often referred to as â€Å"mercy killing†. This is the deliberate killing of a patient with their voluntary consent, without their consent when impossible, or without their consent but not sought. Euthanasia should be practiced because, it reduces the amount of tragically self-inflicted suicides, it gives terminally ill patients a painless death, and their vital organs can be saved and used to save other patients. In November of 1994, Oregon voters approved Euthanasia by a vote of fifty one percentRead MorePhysician Assisted Suicide1249 Words   |  5 Pagesinsurance company, or ourselves decide? Should nature be able to take its course with no interference from humans? For years, physicsians have not been allowed to help patients with suicide. Dr. Jack Kevorkian brought it to the forefront when he was arrested and senteced to over 60 years in prison even though the families of his patients showed their gratitude towards him. Recent laws in Montana, Oregon, and Washington have started the trend of Physican assisted suicide, but the U.S Attorney General’s